Thursday, September 20, 2012

Sweet Uncertainty Is A Powerful Motivator

What makes a great training session from a psychological point of view? A coach we work with closely in Montréal, Charles Gaston-Couturier, describes the challenge of a good training set using something he calls 'Sweet Uncertainty', based on work by Brunelle in 1988 [1].

Visually it looks a little like this:
To the left side of the graph we have a goal that is so far within your capabilities it is too easy and boring. On the right side is a goal so hard you know it is impossible to complete, to attempt it would be futile. Somewhere in-between lies a tough challenge, one you're not sure whether it's possible to complete or not, a challenge that once set becomes very motivating.

The most common example of this form of motivation is when you set yourself a race or event goal, for instance "Next year I want to swim that hard 10km race" or "I want to complete an Olympic Distance Triathlon in 2:30".

The Flow State

Psychology Professor Mihaly Csíkszentmihályi describes how the motivation of a challenge leads to the 'flow state' [2] where all our emotions and our entire focus are aligned to help us achieve the goal:

"The flow state is being completely involved in an activity for its own sake. The ego falls away. Time flies. Every action, movement, and thought follows inevitably from the previous one... Your whole being is involved, and you're using your skills to the utmost."

In the sporting world we know the flow state as 'the zone'. Attempt something too easy and we become bored but try something too hard or beyond our skill level and we become anxious and demotivated by the futility of trying. Both extremes make it impossible for us to enter the zone, instead we need that point of uncertainty somewhere in-between.

Setting Yourself Regular Challenges

What is interesting to note is that this form of goal setting motivation (known technically as 'extrinsic self determined') doesn't just exist for mid and long term goals, it works session by session too.

So if you are bored or lacking motivation, try setting yourself regular mini-challenges in your training. This could be a set you haven't tried before or times and distances you are not sure you can complete. It might be leading your lane in the squad through a CSS set or matching a training partner who is slightly quicker than you.

Such challenges don't need to be set in every session because looking forward to them will motivate you in other sessions building up to them. But find that point of sweet uncertainty and motivation (and flow) will be yours.

Swim Smooth!

[1] "La supervision de l'intervention en activité physique" by Brunelle, Drouin, Godbout et Tousignant
[2] "Beyond Boredom and Anxiety: Experiencing Flow in Work and Play" by Mihaly Csíkszentmihályi

8 comments:

Michael. said...

May the flow be with you!

Alias said...

"Improvement begins at the edge of your comfort zone." - Jonathan Rowson

harry @ GoalsonTrack.com said...

Great advice on goal setting.

You may want to check out http://www.GoalsOnTrack.com, a very nicely built web app designed for tracking goals and todo lists, and supports time tracking too. It's clear, focused, easy to navigate, worth a try.

zackme said...

Hello,
a question outside this topic:
I want to have stronger legs(maybe more so for sprint): shall I do board kicking exercices with/without fins, small/large ones? Thank you.

Zack

Adam Young said...

Hi Zack, tell us a bit more about your swimming, how you rate yourself and what your goals are.

zackme said...

Thanks. Well you already told me that I do not need to use my legs a lot to swim faster, which I understand. Independantly on swimming, I just would like stronger thighs.
I swim about every day, about 1.5km, free stroke, averaging 55s/50m, doing sets from 200-400m. I am 188cm, thin, long arms, need 46 strokes/50m.
Zack

Adam Young said...

Hi Zack,

Strong thighs may actually harm your swimming as they will probably make your legs more sinky. Just so you know...

If you want to build them personally I would do other sports to build them as good kicking uses the glutes and hip flexors more than the quads and is unlikely to give you the development you might be looking for.

To develop your swimming I'm sure you need an old round program to tune things up like on our DVDs. Let us know if you have any video of your stroke.

Adam

frank said...

Hi, nice post. Would you please consider adding a link to my website on your page. Please email me back and I would be happy to give you our link.

Thanks!

Frank
frank641w@gmail.com